Catégories
EN

Theses by publication in Spain: output, authorship and integrity concerns

Authors : Álvaro Cabezas-Clavijo, Nazaret Barriga, Rafael Repiso

Theses by publication are accepted in most Spanish universities, yet there is little empirical evidence on the scientific output that supports them or on the role doctoral candidates play in that output, and it is not even possible to determine what share of all theses defended in the country follow this format. To address this gap, we analysed a sample of 338 theses by publication defended in Spain in 2025 and 2026, identified in the Teseo database and downloaded in full text. On average, each thesis included 4.0 works, of which 3.0 were articles indexed in Scopus, and 61.1% of these articles appeared in first-quartile SJR journals.

The doctoral candidate was first author in 81.1% of the articles and held an intermediate position in 12.1%, while 17 candidates (5.4%) were not first or sole author of any article in their compendium. As for publication venues, MDPI was the main publisher, with 23.2% of the articles, and 40.6% of the candidates published at least one work from their compendium with it. Overall, 45.4% of the candidates used so-called grey publishers, such as MDPI or Frontiers, at least once, and for almost 10% of them these publishers were the only outlet for the compendium.

We also detected other infrequent but questionable practices, such as the inclusion of works published in journals delisted from Scopus or in special issues guest-edited by the candidates themselves, works still under review, and articles included in two different theses. Taken together, these results point to the need to clarify regulations on theses by publication, in particular regarding the candidate’s authorship of the works linked to the thesis and the quality criteria required of publication venues.

Theses by publication should also be identified in a standardised way in official registers, so that they can be retrieved and monitored.

DOI : https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2611.24350

Catégories
EN

Fragmentation as Administrative Burden in Read and Publish Agreements

Author : Christy Jarvis

Read and Publish (R&P) agreements have become an increasingly important mechanism for advancing open access publishing, yet libraries continue to report substantial administrative effort associated with their implementation despite ongoing investments in publisher workflows, institutional tools and community standards.

This paper synthesizes literature from scholarly communications, public administration, organizational studies and information systems to examine why administrative burden persists.

Building on these complementary perspectives, it proposes fragmentation across publisher ecosystems as a conceptual framework for understanding the operational work required to administer institutional portfolios of R&P agreements.

The framework suggests that administrative burden arises not simply from the complexity of individual agreements but from the cumulative effort required to reconcile differences among publisher workflows, metadata, reporting practices, eligibility rules and support models.

Viewing libraries through this lens highlights their role in performing interoperability work that transforms fragmented publisher implementations into a coherent institutional service.

The paper concludes by considering the implications of this framework for libraries, publishers, consortia and standards organizations, arguing that future progress will depend not only on improving individual systems but also on reducing fragmentation across the broader scholarly communications ecosystem.

URL : Fragmentation as Administrative Burden in Read and Publish Agreements

DOI : https://doi.org/10.1002%2Fleap.2124

Catégories
EN

Biological Repositories as Reproducibility Infrastructure: Enabling Reliable Science in the Biosciences

Author : Chonnettia Jones

Reproducibility is a cornerstone of scientific progress, ensuring that discoveries can be verified, built upon, and translated into meaningful advancements.

In the biosciences, transparent data and code are necessary but not sufficient; reproducibility also requires reliable infrastructure with reliable access to rigorously characterized research materials.

Biorepositories play a pivotal role by archiving and safeguarding materials, meticulously curating provenance and metadata, providing visible indicators of material quality, and sustaining durable records that stand the test of time.

Working in collaboration, the research community and biorepositories can uphold the integrity of research by supporting research reproducibility, extending published findings to unlock the full potential of scientific research.

DOI : https://doi.org/10.1162/99608f92.a05ce2a0

URL : Biological Repositories as Reproducibility Infrastructure: Enabling Reliable Science in the Biosciences

Catégories
EN

Metadata conflicts and their impact on DataCite metadata completeness in disciplinary research data repositories

Author : Dorothea Strecker

This paper presents results from a study that investigates how eight disciplinary research data repositories from the geosciences and social sciences navigate metadata conflicts – conflicts in implementations of the same standard and inter-standard conflicts – and how these conflicts affect the completeness of DataCite metadata.

It combines results from analyzing DataCite metadata records, structural differences between three disciplinary metadata schemas and the DataCite Metadata Schema, and a direct comparison of two metadata records describing the same dataset.

The results show that both conflicts in implementations of the same standard and inter-standard conflicts contribute to incomplete DataCite metadata. In addition to inherent differences between the metadata schemas, workflows and conscious decisions by the repositories also contribute to these conflicts.

Some of these conflicts could be resolved by updated metadata crosswalks, emerging initiatives for retroactive collaborative metadata enrichment, the implementation of metadata application profiles or schema updates. Other conflicts can’t be resolved or are strongly connected to the repository mission.

The results also highlight that metadata completeness is multifaceted, and assessment requires careful consideration of context.

DOI : https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2603.25468

Catégories
EN

Scientific rigor beyond open science: Faculty perspectives on research quality and evaluation

Authors :  Holly Cordner, Gabrielle Y Garza, Isabelle Freiling

In recent years, policy reforms and funding mandates have accelerated the adoption of open science practices. These practices are increasingly being promoted and mandated to enhance transparency and replicability.

As such, they may serve as signals of the quality of a paper. However, transparency and replicability are only parts of what makes a study rigorous, and far less attention has been paid to how this emphasis on open science practices relates to the criteria researchers use to evaluate scientific rigor.

Drawing on in-depth interviews with tenure-line faculty across disciplines, we examine how researchers understand scientific rigor and how they interpret the growing use of open science practices as signals of quality. Faculty consistently valued open science for improving transparency and accessibility but emphasized a broader set of criteria they consider equally important for rigorous research, including theoretical grounding, appropriate methods, accurate claims, and ethical considerations.

Many noted that these dimensions of rigor are not always fully captured by open science frameworks or by journal badges that indicate adherence to open science practices. Faculty also expressed mixed views about the extent to which open science practices function as meaningful indicators of research quality across disciplines and methodologies.

Our findings suggest that while open science can strengthen scientific rigor, evaluation systems that treat transparency and replicability as prominent evaluative signals may affect perceptions of what constitutes rigorous research.

These findings have implications for the design and implementation of research evaluation frameworks that reflect the multidimensional and context-dependent nature of scientific rigor.

URL : Scientific rigor beyond open science: Faculty perspectives on research quality and evaluation

DOI : https://doi.org/10.1093/reseval/rvag061

Catégories
FR

Étude et classification des contextes de citation pour une construction d’indicateurs relationnels sémantiques

Author : Yutong Fei

Depuis la première proposition d’une typologie de catégories sémantiques citationnelles en 1965 par Eugene Garfield, pour mieux comprendre les raisons et les fonctions de l’acte de citer, ce sujet de recherche n’a cessé de susciter l’intérêt de plusieurs disciplines, telles que la sociologie des sciences, la linguistique, la bibliométrie et l’informatique.

Dans cette perspective, les travaux empiriques ont évolué, passant des entretiens sur les motivations de citation à la classification sémantique des contextes de citation, c’est-à-dire les passages textuels entourant une référence dans un article scientifique.

Avec le développement des approches informatiques, cette classification tend aujourd’hui à s’automatiser, donnant lieu à des services à valeur ajoutée intégrés dans les systèmes de recommandation de citations destinés à améliorer la recherche bibliographique.

Or, comprendre la citation suppose d’abord de préciser ce que recouvre la sémantique citationnelle et d’en saisir la genèse. Celle-ci ne se réduit pas à une analyse linguistique, mais reflète les stratégies scientifiques, sociales, rhétoriques, et discursives des auteurs. Les formes de citation résultent ainsi de multiples facteurs, tels que les spécificités disciplinaires, les pratiques de recherche ou encore l’évolution des normes éditoriales au fil du temps. Réduire les contextes de citation à de simples ressources d’entraînement pour des applications industrielles appauvrit la compréhension de la citation, en négligeant les tensions qui structurent cette complexité.

Cet enjeu est au cœur de cette thèse, qui construit un corpus de contextes de citation prenant en compte les facteurs influençant la production du discours citationnel, notamment la diversité disciplinaire et éditoriale, afin de proposer une typologie des différentes manières de citer.

Le corpus réunit 8 358 contextes issus de 157 revues internationales, publiées entre 2020 et 2023, période marquée par une tendance à la standardisation des politiques éditoriales autour des valeurs d’ouverture et de transparence de la recherche. En complément de cette analyse discursive, une étude exploratoire fondée sur des entretiens semi-directifs avec trois acteurs phares du marché de la citation a été réalisée pour interroger l’usage industriel des contextes de citation.

Les 50 catégories de citation dégagées dans cette thèse révèlent une grande diversité sémantique, façonnée par la tension entre les caractéristiques disciplinaires du discours citationnel et la standardisation éditoriale. Les différentes manières de construire le savoir propre à chaque discipline se reflètent dans cette diversité, telle qu’elle s’exprime à travers la dimension discursive de la citation, car la construction du savoir et celle du discours sont indissociables, particulièrement dans les SHS.

Par ailleurs, la structuration de cette diversité discursive par les lignes éditoriales constitue un enjeu industriel, en lien avec la future exploitation des contextes de citation dans les bases de données. Les résultats de cette recherche doctorale montrent les effets des cadres politiques et institutionnels de la recherche sur les cultures discursives de la citation.

De même, ils montrent de quelle manière l’implémentation des contextes de citation ouvre la voie à de nouvelles formes d’exploitation de la publication scientifique ouverte, qui offre aux acteurs du marché des opportunités renouvelées de marchandisation.

URL : https://hal.science/tel-05687014v2

Catégories
EN

The future of scholarly blogs: Scholarly bloggers’ perspectives on long-term preservation

Authors : Catharina Ochsner, Heinz Pampel

Scholarly blogs are an important venue for scholarly communication; however, they are not yet integrated into the preservation workflows of digital research and information infrastructures, which places their long-term access at risk.

By using Star and Ruhleder’s (1996) dimensions of information infrastructure as a theoretical framework, in this study we investigate social and organizational factors that impact blog preservation and derive implications for the implementation of blogs into an information infrastructure.

We conducted and qualitatively analyzed 13 semi-structured interviews with scholarly bloggers to identify bloggers’ perceived challenges concerning blog preservation and their requirements for an information infrastructure tasked with preserving scholarly blogs. We found that participants named or indirectly described existing infrastructure institutions and their services that are already working toward preserving the scholarly record.

The findings suggest extending the scope of existing infrastructure institutions to include scholarly blog preservation.

URL : The future of scholarly blogs: Scholarly bloggers’ perspectives on long-term preservation

DOI : https://doi.org/10.1002/asi.70126